Contributions to renowned conferences and publications in recognized scientific journals are the currency of science. For you as a scientist it is crucial to make your research visible and to publish your findings. This is what dubious organizers and publishers and fraudulent publication offers try to exploit.
What are Predatory Journals?
Dubious journals, also known as predatory journals, pursue a business model in which you are offered to publish your scientific work for a fee, without a quality assurance process and editorial work, as is usual for serious journals. Contents of these dubious journals are often not indexed in the relevant professional databases and thus remain hidden from the professional community.
Increasingly, many dubious journals and publishers are also contacting (especially young) scientists directly by e-mail and asking for contributions. With such inquiries special caution is required!
Checklists and Criteria for Seriousness
However, it is not always easy to recognize the black sheep. If you are considering a publication in a journal that is not known in your professional circles, you should examine it carefully. Evaluation portals and our checklist can be a guide. Our checklist should help you to assess the seriousness of journals; if you answer one or more questions in the checklist with "yes", you should be suspicious and possibly consider a publication in another journal.
Checklist Predatory Journals
Directories and Evaluation Tools
If it is an Open Access journal, check whether it is listed in the Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ).. Only quality-checked titles from trusted publishers can be found here.
In Quality Open Access Market (QOAM) the quality of individual journals is assessed by scientists and scholars themselves. Information on editors, the peer review process, business policy, workflows and personal experience is entered here.
Potentially dubious journals, on the other hand, are included in the negative list "Stop Predatory Journals". Before submitting articles to journals listed there, we strongly advise you to check your selection very carefully.
With the emergence of fraudulent behavior in the publishing industry, many rogue publishers have expanded their business models to make additional profits from predatory conferences. At first glance, such conferences may appear to be serious and scientifically based events, but it soon becomes clear that they do not offer any scientific added value.These conferences are organized by companies whose only goal is to make money with the conference fees – moderators and participants are exploited
The following checklist should help you to recognise if the conference is a dubious one. Consider this checklist as a basis for evaluation and not as a complete list of possible indicators.
Checklist Predatory Conferences
Consulting and Training Offers
If you would like to deal with the topic more intensively, then take part in one of our courses:
If you have become suspicious of the lists, our Open Access Team will be happy to do more in-depth investigations for you.